More than a week later, I received a call from the clerk of the Criminal Tribunal of Beicheng District Court, asking me to cross-examine the reply letter from the planning department.

Because Xie Ling and her master were the full attorneys for Wei Ningshan and his father in the civil litigation incidental to the criminal case, there was no need to take the two defendants out of the detention center again, and the attorneys could just cross-examine on their behalf.

Zhao Jing happened to be sent on a business trip to other provinces these days, so I had to go to the court alone again.

Zhao Jing and I have also researched the issue of civil compensation for illegal buildings or structures on the Internet before, and found that most cases only support partial losses, so we feel there is nothing to explain to the court. If the reply letter from the planning department is true,

If we decide that the glass in our house is an illegal structure, then it can only mean that it is going to rain and my mother wants to get married, so let it be.

In an office of the Criminal Tribunal of Beicheng District Court, I saw the reply letter from the planning department.

The general meaning is: the glass curtain wall on the terrace of Room 1501, Building 3, Jinxiu Garden, was constructed without planning permission and violated the provisions of Article 32 of the "Urban Planning Law of the People's Republic of China" and should be deemed an illegal structure.

and does not belong to the "China

Article 40 of the Urban Planning Law of the People's Republic of China stipulates that corrective measures can still be taken. As for the above-mentioned situation where the original glass of the terrace glass door of the house was replaced with sound-insulating glass, it did not violate the provisions of relevant planning laws and regulations. This unit believes that it is

It is not an illegal structure.

After I finished reading the reply, Xie Ling, who arrived before me and came to cross-examine alone, sat on a chair opposite me, looked at me triumphantly, and said: "Hey, little rookie, you still want to

Will the full amount be compensated according to the price?”

I ignored her and said to the clerk: "Comrade clerk, when will the presiding judge come over?"

The clerk said: "Oh, she is currently receiving other parties in Court No. 2. Please sit here for a while and wait a moment."

Xie Ling and I sat face to face on two chairs only one meter apart. We stared at each other for five or six minutes before the female presiding judge hurried over.

After sitting behind his desk, the presiding judge said: "I'm sorry to keep you waiting. Have you all read this reply?"

I said, "I've seen it."

Xie Ling said: "Yeah."

The presiding judge said: "Then you can start to express your cross-examination opinions on the reply letter. Clerk, the recording head is ready."

The clerk said: "It's done."

The presiding judge said: "Let the plaintiff and the defendant start speaking, whoever comes first."

Xie Ling was the first to say: "I have no objection to the nature of this reply letter, but I have objections to its opinion that the soundproof glass on the terrace is not an illegal structure. I think the soundproof glass, like the curtain wall outside, is not originally made from the original No. 3 Jinxiu Garden Building.

Fang'an's contractor

Installed, which means that they were not constructed according to the design drawings. Therefore, both the outer glass curtain wall and the soundproof glass on the terrace door should be considered illegal structures and should not be protected by law. Let alone obtain

Compensated."

The presiding judge said: "Are you done?"

Seeing that Xie Ling did not answer, the presiding judge continued: "Wei Ze, please express your opinion on the reply letter."

I said: "There is no objection to the authenticity of the reply letter. Its relevance and legality will be decided by the collegial panel."

Xie Ling sneered and said: "We must win! Wei Ze shouldn't get a penny, otherwise it will be a shady case."

The clerk said: "Lawyer Xie, should this sentence also be recorded in the transcript?"

Xie Ling said: "Remember!"

The presiding judge said: "Okay, one more thing is that if the collegial panel finally determines that the glass in Wei Ze's house is or is part of an illegal structure, then it will need to clarify the cost of Wei Ze's building these glasses and distinguish between glass

The purchase price of raw materials and the labor cost of installation.”

Xie Ling's face changed at this time and she said: "What, is it an illegal construction? Do I still have to pay the cost?"

The presiding judge said: "I didn't say that."

Xie Ling said: "I don't care, I don't think there is any need to clarify."

I said: "I have previously asked the construction company that installed the two glass windows for me to issue a cost list to clarify the purchase price of the raw materials for the glass and the labor costs for the installation and construction."

After saying that, I took the list out of a document bag I carried with me, got up and put it on the presiding judge's desk.

In fact, this list was issued by Zhao Jing at the request of Xiaoli’s boyfriend from the affiliated company.

The presiding judge glanced at me and said, "Young man is quite knowledgeable."

Xie Ling sneered and said, "I'm just a sophomore, what do you know?"

The presiding judge said: "Weize, are you presenting this list as evidence?"

I said, "Yes, so that you don't have to waste time doing appraisals and let Wei Ningshan and his son spend more time in the detention center, hehe."

Under normal circumstances, the defendant is held in a detention center under the management of the Public Security Bureau before the criminal judgment takes effect. Only after the judgment takes effect will he be transferred to a prison under the management of the Department of Justice.

Everyone in the know knows that the conditions in detention centers are worse than in prisons, not because of anything else, but because the prison rooms and even the outside activity space are basically larger than those in detention centers, because detention centers are built near cities, and prisons

They are all located in further suburbs or rural areas. Moreover, the personnel in the same cell in the detention center are more mobile, while the personnel in the cell in the prison are relatively fixed, so most prisoners hope to be transferred from the detention center to the prison as soon as possible to serve their sentences.

The presiding judge said: "Lawyer Xie, please take a look at it and give your opinion on the cross-examination. By the way, do you want a cross-examination period?"

Xie Ling said: "The period for proof has passed and there will be no cross-examination."

I said: "The list I just got yesterday is evidenced by the signature of the decoration company above."

This is what I call treating others in their own way, hehe.

Xie Ling paused for a moment, glared at me, stood up, walked to the presiding judge, picked up the list, took a look at it, and said: "No cross-examination period, huh, it's a waste of everyone's time, and I don't want to make another trip, eh

, I have objections to the three properties of this list.”

The presiding judge said: "Is it over?"

Seeing my slight smile, Xie Ling rolled her eyes at me and said, "It's not like he didn't say so much because he was short of words. I'm just too lazy to pay attention to his useless evidence."

The presiding judge said: "Okay, do you have anything else to say?"

I said: "No more."

Xie Ling: "..."
Chapter completed!